The Best 4 Slice Toasters in 2024

Modern toasters can handle anything from ordinary white bread to the tastiest bagels. When you have to feed a crowd every morning, then it’s essential to have a 4-slice toaster.

Dozens of models are on the market, and they vary in quality and features. After conducting comprehensive reviews of many of these models, we’ve identified the 10 best.

Keep reading to find the 4-slice toaster for your home.

Best 4 Slice Toasters

1. Cuisinart CPT-180MR Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

Sale

Is it acceptable to say that an appliance is gorgeous? This one is, thanks to its slightly Art-Deco vibe. It’s also the top-rated 4-slice toaster, and it’s made by Cuisinart, a trusted name in home goods.

This unit has dual control panels so that it operates like two toasters. Each control panel has a browning dial with six settings so that you get the appropriate level of toastiness every time.

Buttons on the control panels help you ensure success with settings for reheating, defrosting, or perfectly finishing bagels. Other features include dual carriage levers, one-and-a-half-inch slots, and a slide-out crumb tray.

Fans love the three-year warranty on this model, but others wish that the unit popped the toast up just a little higher when it’s done.

If you’re looking for a toaster that you’ll be proud to display, then this is the model for you.

Pros

  • Gorgeous design
  • Dual controls
  • Plenty of setting options

Cons

  • Toast doesn’t pop up very high

2. Sunbeam Wide Slot 4-Slice Toaster

Sale

This is a simple, straightforward four-slice toaster that lacks some of the bells and whistles that more expensive models include. However, that may be just what you want, particularly if you tend to toast the same bread every day of the week.

Like many of the appliances on this list, this one has dual control panels. Each control panel has a dial with darkness settings from one to seven. If you’re toasting a bagel, there’s a button to push, but that’s the only other control.

With extra-wide slots, it’s possible to toast anything, and toast-lift technology lets you remove bread without burning yourself.

Many people like the straightforward functionality of this toaster, but others wish that the cord was placed on the back of the unit instead of the front.

This handy little toaster will help you get ready in the morning.

Pros

  • Straightforward operation
  • Good shade selection
  • Dependable

Cons

  • Cord placement is poor

3. Proctor Silex 4-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster with Cool Wall

Sale

Proctor Silex is a recognizable name in the home goods business, and this high-end toaster is a good selection for consumers who are looking for straightforward functionality.

Equipped with extra-wide slots, you’ll have no trouble toasting bagels and hamburger buns in this toaster. This unit is equipped with a toast boost so that you can easily retrieve your perfectly toasted articles.

The dual control panels let you decide just how you want your toast to be done. Shade selection dials run from one to seven, and there’s a cancel button in the center of each dial.

A cord wrap on the bottom of the appliance keeps things tidy, as do the dual crumb collectors.

Many people describe this toaster as being reliable and well made, but some critics wish that it had buttons for functions like reheat, defrost, and bagel.

With its straightforward operation, this toaster is an asset in the kitchen.

Pros

  • Stays cool to the touch
  • Has a cord wrap
  • Equipped with extra-wide slots

Cons

  • No button functions beyond cancel

4. CUSIBOX Stainless Steel 4 Slice Toaster with Bagel

This is another high-quality toaster that boasts a sleek, retro look that’s bound to appeal to many. While the front and top of the unit are shiny stainless steel, you have your choice of metallic colors on the sides. These include baby blue, black, red, and warm cream.

Dual independent control panels include dials for shade settings from one to six. Buttons on each control panel are used to defrost, toast bagels, or cancel the current function.

The various buttons are highlighted by red LED indicators so you know precisely which setting you’re using.

Praising the one-and-a-half-inch slots, the even toasting, and the speed with which this toaster works. Nonetheless, some people wish that the levers could lift the toast higher for removal.

With great looks and reliable functionality, this toaster is a safe bet.

Pros

  • Looks great
  • Red LED indicator lights
  • Fast toasting

Cons

  • Removing toast can be tricky

5. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster with Brushed and Chrome Stainless Steel Housing

Krups is another trusted name in home goods, and this toaster doesn’t disappoint. This is another one of those sleek and beautiful appliances that you’ll love having on your counter. Don’t be surprised if guests in your home notice it first when they enter the kitchen.

Of course, this model isn’t the 4-slice toaster just because of its looks. It also performs like a dream with dual control panels. Dials manage the level of browning from one to six while push-button functions are available for defrosting, reheating, bagel, and canceling.

This model is all chrome and brushed stainless steel. Combined with blue LED lights, it looks fantastic and works even better.

Fans appreciate the long cord, removable crumb tray, and durability. Critics say that this model is just a little too lightweight. When pushing a button, the whole unit slides across the counter.

With beauty and functionality, this Krups toaster is a winner.

Pros

  • Long cord
  • Looks great
  • Toasts evenly

Cons

  • Too lightweight

6. CUSINAID 4 Wide Slots Stainless Steel Toasters with Reheat Defrost Cancel Function

This is another colorful selection that pairs brushed stainless steel with eye-catching colors like red, blue, and black. This toaster has a cool retro look that will be right at home in many kitchens.

As a wide slot toaster, this appliance can accommodate bagels and thick-sliced bread. The dual control panels are each equipped with shade selector dials that run from one to seven in addition to buttons for canceling the current function, reheating, and defrosting.

With two removable crumb trays and a cord wrap on the bottom, this is a tidy and contained model that looks stylish on the counter.

Users love the retro design and cool colors as well as how well this toaster performs. However, some people are dissatisfied with how shallow the slots are.

This toaster looks beautiful in the kitchen and does exactly what it’s supposed to do.

Pros

  • Cool, retro styling
  • Even browning
  • Nice control panels

Cons

  • Shallow slots

7. BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

This selection is for those of you who have a sleek black and chrome kitchen. The sophisticated styling on this toaster will take your décor up a tone.

Plus, this four-slice toaster with extra-wide slots performs well. Each half of the toaster has its control panel. Each panel has a dial for “shade setting” from one to seven so that your toast comes out perfectly every time.

The panels also have buttons for a bagel, frozen, and cancel, but there’s no reheat button on this one. Both levers can be lifted when toasting is done so that you can safely retrieve your breakfast.

Saying that this toaster is well-made and convenient, many people love it. However, some users wish that this model had indicator lights to tell them when they’ve pushed a button.

With a sleek design and dependable performance, this is an excellent selection.

Pros

  • Even browning
  • Lift a level to safely grab toast
  • Looks nice on the counter

Cons

  • No indicator lights

8. Hamilton Beach Toaster with Wide Slots

This chrome with black accents model is a good 4 slice toaster. Dual control panels make it easy for you to treat this single unit like it’s two toasters.

Use the dials to select how dark you want your toast. There are nine settings so you can dial in on your preferred level of toastiness.

Also included on this toaster are four buttons on each control panel. These buttons are for reheating, defrosting, toasting a bagel, or canceling the current function.

This model also has the toast-boost feature so that you can grab your toast without worrying about burning your fingers.

Fans love the large crumb tray that slides out with ease as well as the many shade settings. Others wish that this model toasted more evenly.

This is a good-looking and reliable toaster that won’t break the bank.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Plenty of shade settings
  • Large crumb tray

Cons

  • Doesn’t always toast evenly

9. CUSIMAX Stainless Steel Toaster with Extra Wide Slot 4 Slice Toasters with Bagel

This is a four-slice toaster with a bit of a twist. Instead of having four slots, it has only two. However, each slot is extra long. This means that each slot can accommodate two standard-size slices of bread or one extra-long slice of bread.

In short, this stainless steel toaster 4-slice model is perfect for people who want to toast oversized bread.

Because there are only two slots, this toaster only has one control panel. On it is a dial for darkness settings from one to six. Use one of the three buttons to reheat, defrost or cancel the current function.

Also of note on this model is the built-in warming rack. A lever on the back of the model raises the rack where you can set croissants and rolls for easy heating.

This toaster is equipped with an easily removable crumb tray and a cord wrap.

Fans love that this toaster can take bagels and long slices of bread. However, some users wish that the markings on the darkness dial were easier to see.

With a warming rack and the ability to accommodate large bread slices, this one’s a winner.

Pros

  • Fits long bread
  • Has a built-in warming rack
  • Look great

Cons

  • Dial markings are hard to see

10. Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 Long Slot Toaster, Reheat, 6 Toast Settings, Defrost, Cancel Functions

Sale

The one-and-a-quarter-inch slots on this easy clean toaster may not be quite wide enough for some of the thickest bagels and bread slices. Nonetheless, this is a beautiful two-slot toaster that easily accommodates four slices of ordinary bread.

Also, because the slots are extra long, toasting slices from your favorite oversized loaves is never a problem.

The single control panel is equipped with a shade selection dial that ranges from one to six. Also included are buttons for cancel/eject, reheat, and defrost. The reheat button also can be used for toasting bagels. Each button features blue LED indicator lights.

This unit is equipped with a drop-down panel on the bottom for releasing crumbs.

Because they love the features of this toaster, many people praise it. Still, some users say that this unit doesn’t toast evenly.

If you’re a fan of oversized loaves of bread, then this is a great selection for you.

Pros

  • Fits large bread slices
  • Has blue LED indicator lights
  • Reliable

Cons

  • Sometimes toasts unevenly

Factors to Consider

Four-slice toasters are the perfect choice when you’re feeding a family because they can toast as many as four slices of ordinary bread at once. However, some of these toasters are better than others. What do you need to look for?

The first consideration is slot size. If you mainly toast conventional bread, then you may not want extra-wide slots. However, slots that are one-and-a-half-inch wide are handy for English muffins, bagels, hamburger buns, waffles, and other treats. Going with wider slots may mean that you use your toaster more than ever.

Slot size also refers to the length of the slots. Four-slice toasters usually have slots that are long enough to accommodate ordinary bread slices. However, artisan bread may be too long for these slots. Some four-slice toasters have extra-long slots for this bread.

You also may want to closely examine the various settings on the toaster. Most of these appliances have dials for determining how dark to make your toast in addition to buttons for special functions like reheating, defrosting, toasting bagels, or canceling the current function. Think about how you want to use your toaster to determine which of these settings is important.

FAQ

What safety features should the toaster have?
Most modern toasters are equipped with basic safety features like having a cool-touch exterior. Many of them also have an automatic shutoff that kicks in when there's a jam or other problem. This helps to prevent fires, and it's a critical component of any toaster.
How often should I clean the crumb tray?
Whether the crumb tray slides out or is a trapdoor on the bottom of the unit, it's a good idea to clean it on a weekly or bi-weekly basis. If your toaster sees heavy use, then you may want to clean it more frequently. You might consider using a canister of compressed air to get out those stubborn crumbs.
Do I have to spend a lot of money to get a good four-slice toaster?
Four-slice toasters are more expensive than two-slice models, but they don't have to break the bank. You can get a great, high-quality model for a little more than $50. Economy models cost a bit less, and you can still get reliable performance out of them.

Summary

We think the 4 slice toaster on this list is the Cuisinart Classic. No one can deny its incredible good looks, and this is the kind of toaster that we’d be happy to see first thing in the morning. With a three-year warranty and extra-wide slots, it’s hard to beat this one.

However, if you’re a devotee of larger loaves, then we think you can’t go wrong with the Elite Gourmet Platinum toaster. We love its warming rack and the extra-long slots.

5/5 - (1 vote)
Scroll to Top