Tortilla presses are a time-tested cooking appliance used throughout history to provide people with the all-glorious tortilla everyone has come to love. While there are stores where one can buy pre-made and packaged tortillas, nothing measures up to homemade cooking.
Therefore we have analyzed various products on the market to discover which presses are worthy of the title of tortilla makers. We have taken specific features into account when analyzing products; everything from the pressing mechanism, material, shape, ease of use, etc. to finding the best models on the market. Continue to find your next tortilla press!
Best Tortilla Makers
1. Victoria 8 Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press
The first product in the review may be considered the cast iron tortilla press. Not only is the Victoria 8 Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press highly rated but it is also considered the tortilla press for flour tortillas.
This cast-iron press from Victoria is highly durable and almost guarantees completely flat tortillas every time thanks to its non-pinch-engineered design. The handle also has a reinforced design, helping to make it easier to press and more stable.
Consumers are mostly satisfied with the Victoria 8-inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press, but there are a few complaints. For the most part, consumers call this a five-star tortilla press and claim that it works like a charm! However, there is a group of consumers who claim the press is poorly made and that the handle has snapped on them.
In conclusion, the Victoria 8 8-inch cast Iron Tortilla Press is among the tortilla press options on the market. Victoria itself has been in the tortilla press business since 1939 so they have plenty of experience in creating reliable tortilla presses.
This item, in particular, is likely best for those looking for a family dinner night tortilla press (may we suggest Taco Tuesday), rather than catering to a large crowd.
Features
- Reinforced cast-iron design
- Engineered to avoid pinching
- Multi-functional: also good for empanadas, arepas, etc.
- Cast iron seasoned at high temperatures with 100% non-GMO vegetable flaxseed oil
- Comes with an extra screw for the lever
- Includes detailed instructions manual
- Dimensions: 9.5″ x 8″ x 2.5″
- Color: black (cast iron)
Pros
- Engineered to avoid pinching
- Can be used to make dishes other than tortillas
- Perfect circular shape
- Ideal for flour tortillas
Cons
- The 8-inch size is relatively small
2. Alpha Living Tortilla Press and Pataconera
The next model in review is reminiscent of a traditional Mexican tortilla maker. The Alpha Living Tortilla Press and Pataconera is a highly durable, effective, traditional cast iron tortilla press. In terms of design, the Alpha Living Tortilla Press and Pataconera bring nothing new or revolutionary to the table, but it is highly durable so you will likely only ever need this tortilla press.
It also has a different aesthetic than many of its cast-iron counterparts. This model sports a greyish, black cast iron color, which may or may not fit in with your kitchen decor.
Consumers are mixed about the durability of this model, despite its high-grade cast iron construction. While there are plenty of anecdotal approvals from consumers, there are many non-dismissible reviews about the tortilla press breaking after only a few uses.
The most notable seems to be the handle breaking for some users with only one or a few uses. However, the description does state that added pressure is unnecessary when pressing the tortillas; so this could explain why some are having success with this unit and others are not.
In conclusion, if you want a very traditional press that is also a simple one-press tortilla maker, this may be the model for you. This press is multi-purposeful as well, as it can be used to make empanadas and dumplings. Overall, the Alpha Living Tortilla Press and Pataconera is a highly useful tortilla press that is also simple to use and clean.
Features
- Makes 7-7.5″ tortillas
- Multi-functional: also makes patacones, tombstones, empanadas, dumplings, etc.
- Heavyweight, cast iron construction
- Easy, wipe-clean design
- Compact design
- Dimensions: 7.5″ x 7.5″ x 1.5″
- Weight: 4.1 lbs
- Color: grey and black (cast iron)
Pros
- Heavyweight cast iron design
- Multi-functional and makes a wide array of foods
- Easy to use, highly durable
Cons
- N/A
3. Uno Casa Cast Iron Tortilla Press
The next model in review is the Uno Casa Cast Iron Tortilla Press it is another quality example of a cast iron tortilla maker. It shares all of the traditional design features that most tortilla presses do.
With two cast iron plates and a cast iron handle, this model is heavyweight and therefore effective for making smoothly flat tortillas. This tortilla press from Uno Casa comes pre-seasoned, which means the plates have been treated and the unit is prepared to be used right out of the box.
As with many of the presses in review, this model is capable of pressing more than just tortillas.
Generally speaking, consumers consistently mention the sturdiness and longevity of this tortilla press from Uno Casa. Another frequently mentioned feature is the solidness of the plates and the positive effect that has on pressing flat tortillas.
While it is not a deal-breaker for most people, many consumers seem to have the same issue of the handle bolt not arriving with the unit.
In conclusion, the value of this Uno Casa Cast Iron Tortilla Press is high. The unit, for one, is highly durable and makes a quality tortilla. Second, the press comes pre-seasoned, totally ready for use upon arrival, and also includes 100 pieces of parchment paper for easier, cleaner presses. That is a whole lot of value for one press at a very reasonable price.
Features
- Makes 8″ tortillas
- Pre-seasoned and ready to use out of the box
- Multipurpose: also makes patacones, dumplings, arepas, etc.
- High-grade cast iron construction
- Comes with 100 pieces of parchment paper
- Extra screw set
- Dimensions: 9.8″ x 7.9″ x 2″
- Weight: 7.94 lbs
- Color: black (cast iron)
- Comes with an e-book of recipes
- FDA approved
Pros
- Pre-seasoned and ready for use right out of the box
- Comes with parchment paper for cleaner pressing
- Heavyweight construction
- Comes with an e-book of recipes for added versatility to your cooking
- FDA approved
Cons
- While it is highly durable, the cast iron makes the press slightly heavy
4. Norpro 6″ Tortilla Maker
Next up in the tortilla press reviews is the Norpro 6″ Tortilla Maker. This press is designed like most tortilla presses with two round plates and a press handle. This model, however, is made from high-grade aluminum so it is lighter than many of the competition’s cast-iron models.
This makes the unit slightly easier to store and also easier to work with. Additionally, the unit can be stored upright with no issues (saving space is always a plus). The 6″ Tortilla Maker is great for small taco dishes and for making a large number of tortillas for entertainment/catering purposes.
Consumers are rather split on the quality of this tortilla press from Norpro. Some consumers are satisfied and believe the press is worth it. Others claim that the press is weak and does not press flat, and some have even noted the press decomposing and leaving metal shards in some tortillas.
While there are positive reviews to be read, the negatives are pretty noteworthy and may cause pause when shopping for a press.
In conclusion, the Norpro is a great beginner’s tortilla press. While it is light, easy to store, and convenient to handle, there are some things to consider before pulling the trigger on this model. The lightweight nature of the model makes pressing completely flat tortillas harder than iron-cast models.
Features
- Makes 6″ tortillas
- One-press tortilla making
- Multi-functional: also makes pitas, flatbreads, etc.
- Cast aluminum design
- Easy, wipe-clean design
- Compact design for easier storing
- Dimensions: 8.37″ x 6.25″ x 2″
- Weight: 1.5 lbs
- Color: Silver
- Comes with recipes
Pros
- Comes with recipes
- Lightweight, easy to store
- Easy to clean and use
Cons
- Makes small tortillas – 6″ (although that may be what you want!)
5. Advanced Royal Champion Tortilla Press
The next model in review is the Advanced Royal Champion Tortilla Press. This is one of the few models in these reviews that has a few model sizes to choose from. Those sizes are six and a half, seven, eight, and 10 inches.
There is not much that can be said about this cast iron press that has not been mentioned in other cast iron model reviews. Simply put, this cast iron offering from Advanced Royal Champion is another great cast iron option to choose from.
However, the fact that there are multiple-size models to choose from adds a value that many other models cannot.
Consumers are split about this cast iron model from Advanced Royal Champion. Many consumers find it to be heavy-duty and reliable. However, others have noted flaking in the plate coating, leaving metal shards in their tortillas.
This is a pretty big negative to weigh against the positives offered by this tortilla press model. While the negative notes are alarming, there are numerous positive reviews also.
In conclusion, this model tortilla press is a great option for those looking for multiple-size presses. The Advanced Royal Champion Tortilla Press is also rustproof, which while many models likely are, this model is the only one to list in its features.
Not a deal-breaker? Well, this model is plenty capable of handling other cooking jobs than tortillas and is also a breeze to clean. It is a great option for kitchens of any size.
Features
- Available sizes: 6.5″, 7″, 8″, 10″
- Rub with any cooking oil to prep
- Multipurpose: also makes empanadas, arepas, etc.
- Heavy-duty, rustproof cast iron construction
- Hand wash, wipe clean design
- Dimensions: 6.5″/7″/8″/10″ diameter
- Weight: x – 18.24 lbs (10″)
- Color: black (cast iron)
Pros
- The same model available in different sizes
- Multi-purpose pressing ability
- Heavy-duty material, very durable
- Easy to use and clean
Cons
- Not pre-seasoned
- Heavy – ideal for pressing but heavy to pick and store
6. StarBlue 10 Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press
The next model is one of the few big tortilla press models in review. The StarBlue 10 Inch Cast Iron Tortilla Press makes tortillas of that diameter, 10″. This tortilla press is by default great for burrito and quesadilla making.
Just like all of the presses on the market, the StarBlue model is constructed from cast iron. While there are other very viable presses not made from cast iron, cast iron is a tried and true material guaranteed to work for you.
At 12.5 pounds this unit is highly durable and reliable for multiple presses and is certainly built to last a long time.
Consumers constantly note the durability of this tortilla press and also call it an outstanding kitchen device. While some users have replaced the bolts with stronger ones, they still love the product and its flat-pressing ability.
In conclusion, if you are looking for a large tortilla maker this model from StarBlue should be high up on the consideration list. With the full gamut of cast iron press features and resounding positive reviews, there are virtually zero factors to deter you from choosing the StarBlue 10 10-inch cast Iron Tortilla Press.
So wait no longer, make masterful burritos with the help of this tortilla press.
Features
- Makes 10″ tortillas
- Seasoned with 100% pure non-GMO flaxseed oil
- Multipurpose: also makes tacos, empanadas, dumplings, etc.
- Heavy, durable, pure cast iron construction
- Comes with 100 pieces of oil paper
- Dimensions: 10″ diameter
- Weight: 12.54 lbs
- Color: black (cast iron)
Pros
- Comes with oil paper for cleaner pressing
- Heavyweight construction
- Makes well-sized, 10″ tortillas
- Easy to use
Cons
- N/A
7. Smart Cook Heavy-Gauge Manual Restaurant Cast Tortilla Press
One of the tortilla press models in review is this next option, the Smart Cook Heavy-Gauge Manual Restaurant Cast Tortilla Press. As its name states so boldly, this tortilla press model is the only cast iron model whose cast iron is heavy-gauge and restaurant grade.
This is an impressive feature because we can trust that materials intended for restaurant use are going to be safe and have long-term reliability. The design is still similar to most iron cast presses with two round plates and a pressing handle.
While the restaurant-grade material is intended to improve the model’s durability, consumers seem to have overwhelmingly negative things to report about the Smart Cook Heavy-Gauge Manual Restaurant Cast Tortilla Press.
Many users note that the handle has broken and some even claim that the description of cast iron is misleading and untrue. Additionally, some claim that the tortillas it makes are not flat enough. Therefore, practice caution when shopping for this product.
In conclusion, the Smart Cook Heavy-Gauge Manual Restaurant Cast Tortilla Press is intended to be of high quality and last for a while. However, consumers strongly suggest that this simply will not be the case with this model. While it may work for some, there seem to be better options (models in review here) for those looking for a heavily reliable model.
Features
- Makes 7.5″ tortillas
- Multipurpose: also makes pancakes, flatbreads, etc.
- Commercial restaurant-grade, heavy-gauge cast iron construction
- Heavy-balanced press weight
- Easy to clean, wipe down design
- Dimensions: 2″ x 7.5″ x 9″
- Weight: 4.5 lbs
- Color: black (cast iron)
Pros
- High-grade material, built to last
- Easy to use and clean
- Highly durable but lightweight (easier to handle)
Cons
- N/A
8. Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press
The next tortilla press in review is the wooden tortilla press. The Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press is made from oak and walnut hardwood and is a beautiful, as well as highly useful, addition to any kitchen.
The hardwood construction makes this tortilla press highly durable and likely to last years. The hardwood press is also likely the tortilla press for corn tortillas, this is due to the lack of gluten in corn tortillas, something that causes flour tortillas’ dough to retract and thicken up.
Consumers overwhelmingly agree that this press is the real deal. Interestingly, nearly every consumer mentions their satisfaction with the aesthetics of the press, claiming they leave it out at all times because it adds a beautiful, organic look to their kitchen space.
As for its pressing ability, “excellent.” You would be hard-pressed (pun intended) to find a review that speaks poorly of this tortilla press from Central Coast Woodworks.
In conclusion, the Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press is ideal for those gluten-free people out there looking for a reliable corn tortilla press. That is not to say flour tortillas cannot be made with this press, it is simply that this press is more suited for corn tortilla pressing. Either way, this model from Central Coast Woodworks is a phenomenal tortilla press.
Features
- Made from high-quality oak and walnut hardwood
- Multi-functional
- Food-grade oil finish
- Dimensions: 8″ diameter (other sizes available)
- Color: wood grain
Pros
- Beautifully designed, aesthetically pleasing when not in use
- Easy to use
- Highly durable oak hardwood construction
- Great for corn tortillas
Cons
- N/A
9. Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press
The final product in review is another offering from Central Coast Woodworks. The Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press nears the top of the list when it comes to wooden tortilla press reviews.
Like the previously reviewed Central Coast Woodworks model, this unit is durable and makes very pleasing tortillas. Unlike its oak and walnut counterpart, this model is made from only red oak hardwood. The wood design also has a very cultured look and is aesthetically enjoyable.
As with the Central Coast Woodworks model previously reviewed, consumers love this Hardwood Tortilla Press. The descriptions constantly note beautiful craftsmanship and artistic mastery. In addition to the great aesthetic, this tortilla press is highly functional and creates awesome tortillas.
You are certainly not going to find shards of material in your tortillas with this press model! A final note is a perfect size noted by multiple consumers.
In conclusion, this Central Coast Woodworks Hardwood Tortilla Press is among the best models available. This item is great for people concerned with the metal flaking described in other models in the reviews. If you want an easy-to-use, easy-to-clean, and beautiful press, this is the one. The high functionality and aesthetically pleasing nature of this press is unrivaled in these reviews.
Features
- Makes 8″ tortillas
- Made from high-quality red oak hardwood
- Multi-functional: used for flatbreads, tacos, etc.
- Easy use and clean design
- Food-grade oil finish
- Dimensions: 8″ diameter (other sizes available)
- Color: red-brown (wood grain)
Pros
- Aesthetically beautiful for your kitchen space
- Easy to use and clean
- Highly durable build
Cons
- Limited to 8″ tortillas
Conclusion
Taco Tuesdays are begging you to stop buying pre-made tacos and tortillas from the store. We are sure you, your friends, and your family will also appreciate some homemade tortillas. Having made it through the reviews, you are now more equipped to consciously begin shopping the market for the tortilla makers.
We suggest giving the models in these reviews a solid look but do not be limited to those written about here if your shopping process takes you elsewhere.
The same practice applies; carefully read descriptions, and reviews, and understand your operation and you should be able to find the perfect tortilla press for your needs. So get yours today and get pressing!
